Ythallo’s Loan to Toronto FC Ends Without a First-Team Opportunity

Toronto FC has confirmed the departure of Brazilian defender Ythallo, who will return to São Paulo after completing his loan spell. Despite high hopes for the 20-year-old, Gitaio was unable to make an impact at the first-team level and spent the entirety of his time in the MLS Next Pro with Toronto FC II.

READ MORE: Jonathan Osorio Shines in Canada's Narrow Victory Over Suriname

A Promising Start That Fell Short

Ythallo arrived in Toronto at the start of the 2024 season with significant expectations. The young center-back, who had previously developed in São Paulo's academy, was hailed as one of Brazil’s rising defensive talents. Standing out for his physical presence and maturity on the ball, Ythallo made his debut in Brazil at the age of 17 and caught the attention of Toronto FC’s scouting team.

Head coach John Herdman expressed enthusiasm for the signing at the time, anticipating Ythallo would eventually become a key figure for the first team. However, despite showing glimpses of his potential, the Brazilian defender did not receive a call-up and was confined to Toronto FC II, where he played 25 matches and accumulated 2,160 minutes. Ythallo managed to score one goal during the season, but his performances were deemed insufficient to earn a promotion.

Questions About Development Strategy

The decision not to involve Ythallo with the senior squad has raised questions about Toronto FC's approach to integrating young talent. Herdman’s choice to overlook the promising defender, particularly during a season where the first team struggled for results, is being scrutinized.

Toronto FC II’s season in the MLS Next Pro offered Ythallo valuable experience, but the lack of first-team opportunities is a missed chance for both the player and the club. With the loan now over, Ythallo returns to São Paulo, leaving Toronto FC fans wondering whether the club failed to capitalize on his potential.

What’s Next for Gitaio and Toronto FC?

For Ythallo, the return to São Paulo marks an opportunity to restart his career in familiar surroundings. Given his age and potential, there is still ample time for him to develop into a top-tier player.

As for Toronto FC, this situation adds to the growing concerns about the club’s handling of young talent. In a season where reinforcements were needed, Ythallo’s lack of opportunities might signal a broader issue in the organization’s player development strategy. Whether this decision will be a regret remains to be seen, but for now, Gitaio’s time in Canada ends as an unfulfilled promise.