John Herdman Departs Toronto FC After Mixed 2024 Season

Toronto FC faces a pivotal moment as John Herdman steps down from his role as head coach. After just one season at the helm, Herdman decided to leave, bringing an unexpected end to a tenure that showed glimpses of promise but ultimately fell short of expectations.

Herdman joined the club in October 2023, tasked with reviving Toronto FC’s fortunes and laying the groundwork for long-term success. While his impact was felt during the 2024 campaign, the team’s failure to secure a playoff spot in the MLS Eastern Conference became a major setback.

READ MORE: Toronto FC Prepares for 2025 After Prince Owusu’s Departure

Highlights and Challenges of 2024

Herdman’s time with Toronto FC included notable achievements, such as competing for a playoff position until the final weeks of the season and reaching the Canadian Championship final. However, the team fell to Vancouver FC in the championship match, and their MLS performance, while improved, still left them outside the postseason picture.

For a club with Toronto FC’s stature and fan expectations, missing the playoffs marked another disappointing chapter in recent history. While Herdman brought progress compared to previous seasons, it wasn’t enough to satisfy the ambitions of the team’s management or supporters.

Herdman’s Reflections

In his farewell statements, Herdman expressed pride in representing Toronto FC but acknowledged that the team’s next phase required fresh ideas. He emphasized that his decision was driven by a desire to focus on new personal and professional goals.

Despite the challenges, Herdman’s departure underscores the complexities of rebuilding a club with Toronto FC’s legacy. His tenure showed progress but highlighted the long road ahead for the team as they aim to return to their former glory.

Toronto FC’s Next Steps

With the 2025 season approaching, Toronto FC is now tasked with finding a new head coach to lead the team forward. The club’s future hinges on its ability to capitalize on recent improvements while addressing ongoing shortcomings.

As Toronto FC begins its search for a replacement, fans will look to the club’s leadership to ensure that the next managerial appointment aligns with their aspirations for success and a return to the MLS elite.