Did this player's departure mid-season benefit Toronto FC?

In the 2024 season, Toronto FC experienced a mix of challenges and pivotal moments, with one of the most significant being the transfer of Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty to CF Montreal.

Marshall-Rutty, a product of Toronto FC’s youth system, showed promise as a key figure for the club's future. At just 20 years old, he had competed in 27 matches for Toronto FC in the 2024 season, scoring one goal and providing seven assists.

READ MORE: An important Toronto FC player on loan, will he return to the team?

Marshall-Rutty’s Development and Transfer

His role as a playmaker was vital, yet it was evident that he did not fully fit into the club's long-term strategy.

On August 9, 2024, CF Montreal officially signed Marshall-Rutty in a deal that amounted to $1.3 million in General Allocation Money (GAM), with $850,000 guaranteed and the potential for an additional $450,000. The transfer was seen as significant, though some speculated that Toronto FC might have prematurely parted with a player of his potential.

Performance at CF Montreal

After his transfer, Marshall-Rutty struggled to make an impact at CF Montreal. He played in 10 matches, accumulating over 700 minutes but failed to register any goals or assists. This performance contrasted sharply with the expectations set by his promising start at Toronto FC, leading to questions about the wisdom of the transfer from his perspective.

Toronto FC continues to think about the 2025 season and its future

As the 2025 season approaches, discussions about Marshall-Rutty’s future continue. With his contract at CF Montreal set to expire in December 2025, there is speculation about a potential return to Toronto FC. Given his roots and history with the club, a comeback could be mutually beneficial, potentially reigniting his career and bolstering Toronto FC’s squad.

This scenario underscores the complexities of managing young talent and the strategic decisions clubs must make in balancing immediate performance with long-term potential.

For Toronto FC, the decision to sell Marshall-Rutty might have been financially advantageous, but the door remains open for his return, offering a narrative of unfinished business between the player and his formative club.